1984 v vendetta comparison essay
Book: The novel and the graphic novel V for Vendetta have similar views on how society is being run. However V for Vendetta was based on since was written before V for Vendetta. Both of these novels are similar in a way like the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government.
Differences and Similarities Between V for Vendetta and 1984
Pssst… we can write an original essay just for you. Problems faced by characters in literature often repeat themselves, and when these characters decide to solve these standard problems, their actions are often more similar than they first appear. On the surface, their actions are very different. Smith takes a mental, passive approach to his problem, while V takes a physical, direct approach. However, when you look at what the two men did in relation to the societies in which they lived, their actions are revealed as very similar.
Both men are patient, tactical, and willing to push themselves just past the limit to the point of self-destruction. They do whatever they can to rebel in the circumstances they are given. Therefore, the contrasting actions taken by the two anti-heroes are not results of their different personalities, but are due to the subtle dissimilarities between the totalitarian oligarchies against which they are rebelling. The governing body in , the Party, does a better job of restraining the general population than Norsefire, the ruling political party, does in V for Vendetta.
With the help of the Thought Police, Newspeak, telescreens, and the Ministry of Love, the Party seeks to control not only what people do, but what they think as well.
This allows the Party to stop rebellion before it begins. The Party officials also implement the deception of continuous warfare to keep the proles below the poverty line and further remove any thoughts of rebellion. However, the main reason for this demise is constant internal struggle. There are three rivaling points of view, one from Creedy, one from Sutler, and one from the police force.
This division in the upper ranks and state of not being able to share one ideology makes it impossible to have complete control over their population, a flaw which seriously weakens Norsefire. Also, the torture methods are primitive, the party officials do not meticulously control the distribution of goods, and they no longer strike fear into the hearts of the people with the same intensity as they once did, following the first outbreak of the St.
Simply put, Norsefire allows itself to be easily exploited by fighting internally instead of controlling the people. These subtle differences between the Party and Norsefire are the difference between control and anarchy. Each thing that Norsefire does to control its citizens, the Party does better. Norsefire monitors citizens with cameras while the Party uses telescreens.
Norsefire uses fingermen to enforce curfew; the Party has the Thought Police. Norsefire causes a fake epidemic with a virus to which it possesses the cure; the Party propagates a fake war with another super-state. Beneath this mask there is an idea, Mr. Creedy, and ideas are bulletproof. V is saying that even when he dies, the idea that he personifies will live on in other like-minded people.
It also alludes to the very beginning of the movie, when the original Guy Fawkes is executed for trying to bring about change in the same that way V is trying. This quote indicates one of the reasons Norsefire is not at the same level of control as the Party. The Party seeks to control both actions and thoughts, and until Norsefire does so just as effectively, it is doomed to a fate of failure at the hands of V, Eve, or another counterpart of Winston.
Winston spends his entire adult life trying to avoid attention from the Party: never partaking in suspicious activities, never expressing his hatred towards the Party, and even constantly monitoring his facial expressions so that his disloyalty is not observed by the telescreens.
Although the reader is led to believe that Winston must not have just been careful enough while committing the thoughtcrimes alongside Julia, crimes that lead to his detainment, the Party actually already knew that Winston was a thought criminal. Because of its extensive surveillance, the Party knew of his thoughtcrime when he had a dream in which a mysterious voice spoke to him, seven years prior to the events in the book.
The party loyalists were always going to arrest and torture him; they were just waiting for the right time.
V, on the other hand, gets away with both figurative and literal murder in his quest to defeat Norsefire. He is more capable of violence than Winston, but it not his physically enhanced body that allows him to attempt a more direct solution.
Norsefire is so concerned with its own affairs, mainly the struggle for power between Sutler and Creedy, that it did not even recognize V as a threat until it was too late. There are far more similarities between Winston and V than there are differences. They both worked in secret for many years prior to their rebellions, both have helpers who support their causes, and both accept the fate of death long before they die.
Accepting such a fate is key, because it means that since they are aware of the consequences of their actions they can act as if they have nothing to lose. These thoughts demonstrate his fatalistic view of the world and foreshadow his eventual demise in the Ministry of Love. His mindset in this quote illustrates the type of world that the Party has created: one where when a man writes in a journal, his next step is accepting death.
Just as the Party creates this attitude in its people, Norsefire curses V with the mentality that he will die, that he should die. The two men are not so similar that if the roles were reversed their actions would have been identical, but their tactics would have been comparable. Both anti-heroes are smart, think they know what they can get away with, and are fighting for a better future not only for themselves, but also for those they love.
These works offer an obvious warning, not to blindly put your faith in powers whose true intentions you do not know, and a lesson from each protagonist.
Winston warns us that people acting within their means, no matter how noble, are not able to succeed against an exorbitantly controlling government. His life reveals that the key to success for all humanity is freedom of thought and liberty in how one chooses to view the world. However, choices have consequences. V teaches us that although he was successful in freeing the people from Norsefire, when you fight fire with fire, the whole world burns. Remember: This is just a sample from a fellow student.
Sorry, copying is not allowed on our website. We will occasionally send you account related emails. Sorry, we cannot unicalize this essay. You can order Unique paper and our professionals Rewrite it for you. Want us to write one just for you? Analysis Of Book by Luis J. Rodriguez Essay. Sympathizing With Coriolanus Essay.
Full Metal Jacket Essays. The Flowers Essays. Hester Prynne Essays. The Lesson Essays. Kurt Vonnegut Essays. Haven't found the right essay? Get an expert to write your essay! Get your paper now. Professional writers and researchers. Sources and citation are provided. This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by professional essay writers. Your time is important. Get essay help. Accessed 21 May Models of political rebellion as displayed in and V for Vendetta.
May You can order Unique paper and our professionals Rewrite it for you Order Now. Your essay sample has been sent. Order now. Hi there! Are you interested in getting a customized paper? Check it out! Having trouble finding the perfect essay? Hire a writer.
Free Essay: Comparing and Contrasting and V for Vendetta The novel and the graphic novel V for Vendetta have similar views on how society is. Manyana westcompare/contrast. Leon, family historians and research papers. - association and contrasting essay pb shelley university of india. By most relevant.
Login Join. Open Document. Comparing and Contrasting and V for Vendetta The novel and the graphic novel V for Vendetta have similar views on how society is being run. However V for Vendetta was based on since was written before V for Vendetta.
Pssst… we can write an original essay just for you.
Since The book was written before V for Vendetta, so perhaps V for Vendetta may have based some of its ideas on this book. Both and V for Vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government.
Comparing and Contrasting 1984 and V for Vendetta Essay
Accueil and v for vendetta compare and contrast essay. Leon, family historians and research papers. By most relevant first ranked search. Cassell, women s divisions in popular culture. One of the handmaid's tale sounds kind of india.
Nightmare visions: 1984 to V for Vendetta
Many contemporary stories seem to resemble classical novels. Settings may be the same, or even initial conflicts may exist, but modern stories can present new content that is different from impressed stories yet. There are governments that control people by fear and manipulation, but the similarities between the two stories are superficial. The purpose of this article is to show that hatred is not only the central principle of party ideology but also leads the leading character Winston Smith to inspire his rebellion. This article also shows that the resistance of Winston Smith was not his own, but was instilled by the parties. The method of the paper is to read the text carefully, mainly considering the main concept of hatred. This article believes that fear is the origin of hatred, hatred gives party power, and is used as a tool to dominate party domination. Keywords: , Orwell, emotion, hatred, love, fear, control, motivation, ideology, power. In the world of "", "British socialism" or "Ingsoc" in news is a totalitarian ideology, unlike the British Revolution he predicts. A comparison of the article of war "Lion and Unicorn" and "" shows that he believes that "Big Brother" regime is his socialist ideal and British socialism distortion.
Since The book was written before V for Vendetta, so perhaps V for Vendetta may have based some of its ideas on this book. Both and V for Vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government.
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. Since The book was written before V for Vendetta, so perhaps V for Vendetta may have based some of its ideas on this book. Both and V for Vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government. The first similarity between and V for Vendetta is that the society is being run by totalitarian rule.
how does the novel 1984 and the movie v for vendetta contrast and compare?
I like this service DigitalEssay. I don't have enough time write it by myself. Tuesday, 13 May V for Vendetta vs. Percy Bysshe Shelly. Binding themselves to powerful messag es, both V and Big Brother become more than tangible individuals. Although V may die and Big Brother may be fictitious, their values survive in the form of effigies. Whoever displays the symbol embodies their image while that which or who is indifferent to the effect. V builds on this concept by sending everyone in England a Guy Fawkes mask. He believes that anyone can become what he represents — the very act of wearing the mask is a political statement that symbolizes anarchy and rebellion. V realizes that the only way to unite England is by eliminating the idiosyncrasies of each individual, which he successfully achieves by transforming them into symbols which are effigies of himself. Furthermore, V says to Mr. Beneath this mask there is an idea, Mr. Similarly, in , the image of Big Brother pervades throughout Oceania.
Models of political rebellion as displayed in 1984 and V for Vendetta
Society is limitless, broad, and expanding. Government is small, limited, and finite. For this reason, the general population should hold no fear in guiding the government in its choices. The book and the movie, respectively, are much more than simple narratives. However, both protagonists are tortured by different sides, and by people from completely opposite ends of the political.
