1491 article review

Customer reviews. Write a review. How does Amazon calculate star ratings? The model takes into account factors including the age of a rating, whether the ratings are from verified purchasers, and factors that establish reviewer trustworthiness. See All Buying Options.

'1491' Explores the Americas Before Columbus

What scientists have learned about the early Americas gives the lie to what Charles C. There are many scholarly disagreements about the research described in How convincing is anthropologist Dean R. Are certain scholars introduced here more believable than others? Why or why not? Probably the most devastating impact from the contact between Europeans and Americans came from the spread of biological agents like smallpox. How can one assay the total impact of the unprecedented calamity that gave rise to the world we live in?

To what degree is the reflexive ethnocentrism of earlier times responsible for the erroneous history of the Americas we have inherited? When Spanish explorer Hernando De Soto brought pigs along on his expedition in order to feed himself and his men, the pigs carried microbes that apparently wiped out the Indian populations in the southeast part of the current United States [p.

In our present global environment, are we as vulnerable as the Indian tribes discussed by Mann? Are there, as he suggests, moral reverberations to be felt as a result of the European entrance into the Americas five centuries ago [p.

Several of the cultures discussed by Mann honored their dead so highly that, in effect, the dead were treated as if they were still alive. What is most interesting about the attitudes toward death and the dead found in the Chinchorro [pp. What kinds of actions did the myth support, and how did it serve the purposes of the settlers? Because of the lack of documentary and statistical evidence for the mass death caused by disease in the New World, experts have argued about the size of the pre-Columbian population.

Yet those who count low, Indian activists say, do so in order to diminish not only the mass death suffered by indigenous peoples, but also the significant achievements of their pre-contact cultures.

Which side does it seem Charles Mann leans toward? Which side do you find more believable? How might the world have been different had the ancient cultures of the Americas survived into the present? The American landscape had come to fit their lives like comfortable clothing. Why did the Indians burn acres of land? Using the words of Harvard biologist Edward O. Indians were a keystone species in most of the hemisphere before the arrival of Columbus.

If our species now has an even greater impact on the world ecosystems, does Mann suggest ways to avoid disasters such as those he delineates in ? How can this problem be resolved? What are the implications of such a claim for the various peoples and tribes that Mann discusses in , and for the descendants of European settlers? People have long believed that being in the wilderness conveys a sense of the sacred.

What happens to this idea of a non-human force in nature if, as Mann concludes, the concept of nature is a human creation? Share: Share on Facebook. Add to Cart. A sweeping portrait of human life in the Americas before the arrival of Columbus. A remarkably engaging writer. Introduction is a groundbreaking study that radically alters our understanding of the Americas before the arrival of the Europeans in , and a necessary book for understanding the long, remarkable story of the indigenous peoples of the Western Hemisphere.

But in fact, in there may well have been more people living in the Americas than in Europe, many of them in urban complexes bigger and more sophisticated than London or Paris.

Older, too: Indian cities were thriving before the Egyptians built the great pyramids. Native people of the Americas developed ways of breeding corn and using the land that were far ahead of other civilizations. In the Amazon, Indians learned how to farm the rain forest without destroying it—a process scientists are studying today in the hope of reviving the practice. Questions and Topics for Discussion 1. About this Author Charles C. Sloan Foundation, among others. He lives with his wife and their children in Amherst, Massachusetts.

Suggested Reading Colin G. Learn More About Second Edition print. LitFlash The eBooks you want at the lowest prices. Read it Forward Read it first. Pass it on! Stay in Touch Sign up. We are experiencing technical difficulties. Please try again later.

New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus. A version of this article appears in print on Oct. 9, , Section 7, Page 21 of the. Summary and reviews of by Charles Mann, plus links to a book excerpt from and author biography of Charles C. Mann.

In this groundbreaking work of science, history, and archaeology, Charles C. Mann radically alters our understanding of the Americas before the arrival of Columbus in Contrary to what so many Americans learn in school, the pre-Columbian Indians were not sparsely settled in a pristine wilderness; rather, there were huge numbers of Indians who actively molded and influenced the land around them. The astonishing Aztec capital of Tenochtitlan had running water and immaculately clean streets, and was larger than any contemporary European city. Indeed, Indians were not living lightly on the land but were landscaping and manipulating their world in ways that we are only now beginning to understand.

The boom in new scholarship on the Western Hemisphere before Columbus is intelligently synthesized in , the engrossing bestseller by the able science popularizer Mann.

Although there is no consensus, and Mann acknowledges controversies, he asserts that the general trend among scientists currently is to acknowledge:. He notes that while Europeans probably derived less benefit from their possession of horses than expected, as e.

Follow the Author

Welcome sign in sign up. Charles C. Mann is a journalist and his new book, while not without flaws, is a journalistic masterpiece: lively, engaging, and full of the latest information about the peoples who lived in the Americas before Columbus joined the two sides of the Atlantic together. Mann draws on wide reading in recent scholarly writing, supplemented by travel to the principal archaeological sites and landscapes involved, as well as by interviews with many of the writers who have challenged older notions about the pre-Columbian past. Recent discoveries, especially in the Amazon region, make some new ideas irresistible; in other cases Mann summarizes recent controversies without committing himself to either side. In general he argues that pre-Columbian American history was just as diverse and as complicated as anything in the Old World, and that Indian skills were not inferior to European skills.

Charles C. Mann's 1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus

Mike is a veteran of the New Hampshire public school system and has worked in grades His role has varied from primary instructor to special needs support. Log in or sign up to add this lesson to a Custom Course. Log in or Sign up. When most Americans think about North and South America before European arrival, they tend to think of scattered tribes of Native Americans. These people lived nomadic lives and were greatly limited by their rudimentary technology. Historian Charles C. Mann would like people to challenge these preconceptions and imagine a vastly more sophisticated group of people. Mann argues that based on newly discovered and discovered evidence that from present day New England to South Carolina the land was covered with farms built by the Native Americans. These farms would be on cleared flat land.

Charles C. Mann New York: Alfred A.

Mann about the pre-Columbian Americas. It was the winner of the National Academies Communication Award for best creative work that helps the public understanding of topics in science, engineering or medicine. The book presents recent research findings in different fields that suggest human populations in the Western Hemisphere —that is, the indigenous peoples of the Americas —were more numerous, had arrived earlier, were more sophisticated culturally, and controlled and shaped the natural landscape to a greater extent than scholars had previously thought. The author notes that, according to these findings, two of the first six independent centers of civilization arose in the Americas: the first, Norte Chico or Caral-Supe , in present-day northern Peru; and that of Formative-era Mesoamerica in what is now southern Mexico.

1491 (Second Edition) Reader’s Guide

John Ydstie. Our founding myth suggests the Americas were a lightly populated wilderness before Europeans arrived. Historian Charles C. Mann compiled evidence of a far more complex and populous pre-Columbian society. He tells John Ydstie about Author Charles C. Mann hide caption. What were the Americas like in , before Columbus landed? Our founding myths suggest the hemisphere was sparsely populated mostly by nomadic tribes living lightly on the land and that the land was, for the most part, a vast wilderness. That's what most of us learned in school, along with a few paragraphs about more highly developed cultures in Central and South America. Research of the past few decades suggests, though, that the Americas were home to more people than Europe when Columbus landed and that most lived in complex, highly organized societies. Mann compiled evidence of the sophistication of pre-Columbian America. And let's start in a very familiar place for Americans, for North Americans, and that is in New England, in the area of the Plymouth Colony. What kind of Indian society was there at the time? MANN: From southern Maine down to about the Carolinas, you would have seen pretty much the entire coastline lined with farms, cleared land, interior for many miles and densely populated villages generally rounded with wooden walls.

1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus

What scientists have learned about the early Americas gives the lie to what Charles C. There are many scholarly disagreements about the research described in How convincing is anthropologist Dean R. Are certain scholars introduced here more believable than others? Why or why not? Probably the most devastating impact from the contact between Europeans and Americans came from the spread of biological agents like smallpox.